LUCERNE, Switzerland — Had just one of her cats
disappeared last October, Isabelle Nydegger would simply have
assumed it had lost its way in the nearby forest or been attacked
by a dog or wild animal.
But first Zeus, a 2-year-old black tabby, vanished. A few
days later it was her 2-year-old black and white tabby, Zorra.
And, finally, the prize of her brood, 4-year-old Merlin, a fluffy
white Siberian whose perky visage remains in her mobile phone
six months later. All were gone within the first couple of weeks
of the fall hunting season.
The cats, Mrs. Nydegger and others are convinced, were shot
by hunters near this central Swiss city and sold to tanners
for their fur, which is used in garments and blankets in the
last western European nation where such a trade is still legal.
Legal, that is, but increasingly stigmatized — and soon Switzerland
is likely to outlaw the practice.
That the first country to outlaw it, Italy, did so only six
years ago reflects the long European history with cat fur and
how quickly the public has soured on its use in the face of
an international campaign to redefine a centuries-old practice
borrowed from traditional Chinese medicine.
While it is legal in Switzerland to shoot feral cats as well
as domestic ones that stray more than 200 yards from their homes,
it is not clear how many cats are hunted every year here and
across the border in France, where residents have also complained
about disappearing felines. One government official put the
number at a couple of dozen. Luc Barthassat, a legislator with
the Christian Democratic People’s Party, said about 2,000, but
members of S O S Chats, an advocacy group, say tens of thousands
are killed.
Estimates of the value of each pelt vary wildly. Mr. Barthassat
said he had been told by tanners that they pay only about $5.
But animal rights advocates say that hunters make much more
than that, noting that some blankets made from 10 pelts sell
at retail for more than $1,700.
But the numbers almost seemed beside the fact this fall, after
a series of TV reports created a public furor. Three TV news
crews from Switzerland and France conducted hidden-camera investigations
that caught tanners who had officially denied trading in cat
fur actively doing so and, in at least one case, explaining
that cat meat was also available.
Soon S O S Chats had collected more than 123,000 signatures
urging the government to ban the practice. Brigitte Bardot and
Michael Schumacher, the popular Formula One driver, signed the
petition, as did leaders of animal-rights groups around the
world.
“This is probably the most popular subject we are dealing
with this year,” said Mr. Barthassat, who has introduced a bill
that would ban the import, export and domestic commercial trade
in cat fur. “By this summer, it will be resolved. It is very
personal for many people because cats are more than animals
to us.”
Regardless of how common it is, news media reports over the
past year across Europe portraying Switzerland as a cat-slaying
haven have helped S O S Chats press its case. “The politicians
must be careful what they say, but that they are helping us
is a good thing,” said Tomi Tomek, the director of S O S Chats,
who has lived since 1981 at a 260-cat shelter nestled in the
rugged western Swiss mountains near Neuchâtel. “All of this
publicity has driven the trade underground, and that is good,
too.”
The matter would most likely have reached the Swiss Parliament
in some form this year regardless of the activism and publicity
because the European Union has required member states to prohibit
the import and export of cat fur by the end of 2008 anyway.
Switzerland is not a member of the Union but does have treaties
that require it to adhere to many of its rules on trade matters.
Mr. Barthassat’s effort to end the domestic trade, however,
is a step beyond the European Union’s demands.
Ms. Tomek said her organization had spent a decade trying
to bring attention to the use of cat fur and the theft of domestic
cats. She said one of the biggest problems her group faced was
to convince people that there really was a trade in cat fur.
“For a long time, nobody believed us because we had no proof,”
she said. “We would call up the tanners and tell them who we
were and ask them, and they would never admit they did this.
Then we started just pretending we wanted to order some cat
fur, and they sold to us. Now we are not seen as liars anymore.”
Armed with a thicket of receipts showing purchases by S O
S Chats of cat fur garments as recently as last August, Ms.
Tomek approached journalists from across Europe, persuading
several to look into the matter.
Until she saw the news reports, Mrs. Nydegger herself dismissed
Mrs. Tomek and others as radicals. But the loss of her third
cat, Merlin, was particularly shocking because he was so loyal
and well behaved, often taking walks with her and her dogs without
a leash. That Merlin would have wandered off, she said, is “just
completely impossible.”
No less than Christophe Darbellay, the president of Mr. Barthassat’s
own party, has said he is alarmed by the growing international
outrage over the trade in a Western European nation otherwise
known for its high regard for animal welfare. The Swiss are
a pet-loving people, more than 60 percent of whom have a dog
or cat, he said. Companion animals are often seen sitting with
owners in restaurants and on public transportation.
“Switzerland is becoming the place where the most cats are
being killed for the import and commerce to sell the cat fur,”
Mr. Darbellay said. “We don’t like to be seen this way.”