PAHRUMP, Nev. - When Michael Miraglia retired and
moved to this booming bedroom community last year, he found that
the builders and landscapers working on his new home spoke so
little English that he was unable to communicate with them.
So after his appointment this year to fill a vacancy on the
town board, Mr. Miraglia, 67, proposed an ordinance declaring
English the official language of Pahrump, an unincorporated
town of about 35,000 people in Nye County, 60 miles west of
Las Vegas. The proposal also denied unspecified town benefits
to "undocumented foreign nationals" and forbade the flying of
any foreign flag without an accompanying American flag.
Mr. Miraglia said that the English Language and Patriot Reaffirmation
Ordinance, as he called it, was intended to bring the community
together under a common language and custom. But its adoption
on Nov. 14, by a vote of 3 to 2, has had the opposite effect.
"It has stirred up anger toward the immigrants," said Arturo
A. Reyes, 40, who came to the United States from El Salvador
two decades ago and became a citizen. Mr. Reyes, who owns El
Cancún Mexican Restaurant on Highway 160, also known as Main
Street, added, "The whole thing is just bad; it's just stupid."
Mr. Miraglia saw it differently.
"These people are breaking the law," he said of the illegal
immigrants here, most of whom are Hispanic, "and they should
be prosecuted somehow."
Pahrump, known for its legal brothels, is not the only community
to pass anti-immigration or English-only measures in recent
months. Similar laws have been adopted in Taneytown, Md.; Farmers
Branch, Tex.; and Hazlton, Pa. In November, Arizona voters made
English that state's official language.
Pahrump's English-only ordinance is likely to be short-lived
because the three board members who voted for it, including
Mr. Miraglia, will be replaced in January by newly elected members
who have said that they oppose the ordinance and want to rescind
it.
[Last Tuesday, the board defeated another proposal by Mr.
Miraglia that would have required illegal foreign workers to
register at the town hall, pay a $200 fee and provide personal
information, including a list of relatives living in the United
States.]
The hullabaloo surrounding Mr. Miraglia's latest proposal
and the language ordinance has caused friction here.
Some Hispanic residents have said that since Mr. Miraglia's
proposals were introduced, people in passing cars have yelled
racial slurs at them.
Lee Rowland, a lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union
of Nevada, said students had been harassed by school officials
for speaking Spanish in private conversations.
And eggs have been thrown at the home of Robert and Liese
Tamburrino, a white couple who protested the ordinance by flying
Italian and Polish flags, representing the heritage of Mr. Tamburrino's
parents. They also received a hate letter calling them "thimble-brained,
knuckle-dragging cretins."
"This is a blatant act of civil disobedience," said Mr. Tamburrino,
59, who bought the flags the day after the ordinance passed.
"I'm breaking the law. Three people spoke for 35,000, and the
way they spoke reeks of prejudice and ignorance. I do not see
the Mexican immigrants as a burden on me or my community at
all. I see them as just trying to feed their families and doing
jobs other Americans don't want to do."
The language ordinance also has burnished an image of Pahrump
as an Old West backwater, which many residents say is inaccurate.
Census data show it is one of the fastest-growing communities
in the nation. The population has surged by more than 45 percent
since 2000. More than 10,000 new homes are under construction
and the city has three golf courses and a country club with
a racetrack for collectible car owners.
"It is very embarrassing to us when things like this happen,"
said Laurayne Murray, a Town Board member who opposed the language
ordinance and the worker registration proposal. "It's unconstitutional,
it's unenforceable and I don't think it reflects how most people
here think."
It is unclear how many immigrants - or non-English speakers
- live in Pahrump. Hispanics were 7.6 percent of the population,
the 2000 census said. But most people say the figure has grown,
a perception supported by the four local elementary schools,
where 12 percent to 17 percent of students are Hispanic.
That apparent growth has unnerved some old-timers here, including
Fred Harvard, 61, who supported the ordinance.
"They come in here, they take the jobs, they take away the
services that belong to real Americans and they don't respect
our flag," said Mr. Harvard, who was born in Nevada. "It's not
right."
Mr. Miraglia's original version of the ordinance would have
created penalties for hiring illegal immigrants and for renting
dwellings and loaning money to them, but he said he removed
those provisions because the town could not afford the cost
of going after landlords and employers.
"People can still speak their own language on their own, but
we just wanted to establish English as the language for the
town of Pahrump so we don't have to publish everything in 7
or 10 different languages," Mr. Miraglia said. "It only benefits
people who come here to learn English because they can be a
part of the community. If you and I were speaking, how would
we communicate if we didn't have a common language? And our
common language is English."
Mr. Miraglia said he learned from an e-mail message from a
constituent that the provision about flying foreign flags violated
freedom of speech. "I sent it to our town manager and we agreed
it probably isn't constitutional," he said.
Ms. Rowland of the A.C.L.U. said that she tried to explain
the problem with the flag provision to Mr. Miraglia and the
rest of the Board on Nov. 14, but her voice may have been drowned
out by hecklers.
Tony DeMeo, the sheriff of Nye County, said he tried to make
the same point when he issued a statement saying that he would
not enforce the restriction on displaying flags.
George Romero, 36, who owns two Mexican restaurants and a
convenience store in Pahrump, said the board did not listen
because it was motivated by "cut-and-dried racism." But Mr.
Romero said he did not think that the board's attitude reflected
that of most of Pahrump, even though one of his restaurants
was painted with anti-Mexican slurs on May 1, when he closed
them in observance of the national "Day Without An Immigrant"
protests.
"There's an immigration problem in the whole country," Mr.
Romero said, "but as far as them taking other people's jobs
in Pahrump, I guarantee you businesses would hire the most qualified
and legalized people if they were available."
Teresa Culhane-Kennedy, manager of the Brothel Art Museum,
a bar outside town with displays that tell the history of legal
prostitution, said she understood how residents felt. "There's
way too many people being allowed to just walk across the border,
it's that easy," she said. "Somebody's got to do something."