LAS VEGAS: A profanity-filled audio recording, apparently
of O. J. Simpson and others during the incident last week that
led to his arrest, surfaced online today.
In the 38-second recording, the voice of a man identified
as Mr. Simpson by TMZ.com, the Web site where it is posted,
is heard repeatedly telling others not to let anyone out of
the room and accusing those present of stealing his property
and trying to sell it.
Mr. Simpson is being held without bail on six felony charges
stemming from the incident; a bail hearing is now scheduled
for early Wednesday morning in Clark County Justice Court before
Judge Ann Zimmerman. The judge may conduct the hearing in person
or by videoconference.
Two sports memorabilia collectors and dealers have told the
police that Mr. Simpson and five other men stormed into their
hotel room at the Palace Station Hotel and Casino, about a mile
from the Las Vegas Strip, on Thursday evening and robbed them
at gunpoint.
Mr. Simpson's account is that he went to the room to take
back property that had been stolen from him, and that there
were no guns involved.
Mr. Simpson, 60, was arrested on Sunday and was booked into
the Clark County Detention Center. One of the men accused of
joining him, Walter Alexander, 46, of Mesa, Ariz., was arrested
on Saturday and released Sunday on his own recognizance, according
to his lawyer, Robert Rentzer. Four others are still being sought
by police.
Mr. Simpson and Mr. Alexander are each charged with six felonies
in connection with the incident, according to Lt. Clint Nichols
of the Las Vegas police: two counts of robbery with a deadly
weapon, two counts of assault with a deadly weapon, one of conspiracy
to commit burglary and one of burglary with a firearm.
It remains unclear exactly what property was taken in the
incident, or to whom it belonged.
"Having said that, the manner in which these properties were
taken, we have a responsibility to look into that regardless
of who the property belongs to," Lieutenant Nichols said. "We
also have some information that the property that Mr. Simpson
allegedly took was not his property.
"It included a lot of sports memorabilia and most of it and
had been signed by Mr. Simpson himself along with some other
property," Lieutenant Nichols said. "I believe there were some
Joe Montana cleats, some signed baseballs and some other stuff."
Capt. James Dillon of the Las Vegas police said that investigators
confiscated two guns that may have been used in the Thursday
incident in an early morning raid on two residences in Las Vegas
on Sunday.
Mr. Simpson told The Associated Press in an interview that
he was innocent and that there were no guns involved in the
incident, which he called a sting operation he organized.
Mr. Alexander's lawyer, Mr. Rentzer, told reporters: "I assured
the authorities that we are not hiding and that he will be available
to us. Until I can meet with my client and hear the facts of
the case and determine my client's exposure, I refuse to discuss
the prospects of plea bargaining."
The two collectors and memorabilia dealers who accused Mr.
Simpson and the other men are Alfred Beardsley of Glendale,
Calif., and Bruce L. Fromong of North Las Vegas, Nev. They told
the police on Thursday night that a group of men, including
two with guns, entered Mr. Beardsley's room at the Palace Station
around 8 p.m. and left with items including photographs and
books signed by Mr. Simpson, lithographs of the former San Francisco
49ers quarterback Joe Montana, and Mr. Beardsley's cellphone.
Mr. Beardsley and Mr. Fromong told the police that the group
had been directed by Mr. Simpson.
In his interview with The A.P., Mr. Simpson gave a different
account. He said that he and some acquaintances left a cocktail
party and went to Mr. Beardsley's room, accompanied by Thomas
Riccio, another dealer and auctioneer of sports memorabilia.
He said Mr. Riccio had alerted him several weeks ago that Mr.
Beardsley and Mr. Fromong were offering to sell items of his,
and that Mr. Riccio had set up a meeting with the two men, supposedly
on behalf of an interested buyer.
TMZ.Com, the web site that posted the audio recording today,
said it was made by Mr. Riccio. It did not say how it obtained
the recording. It described Mr. Beardsley as the object of Mr.
Simpson's evident ire.
In a brief interview today Mr. Riccio said TMC paid him for
the recording, but he declined to divulge the price.
Whether the Riccio audio will be of use to prosecutors is
an open question. Mr. Riccio withheld it from the police for
three days before he sold it to TMZ.Com, a decision that may
taint it, Lieutenant Nichols said.
"He did not turn that over to us immediately, so that evidentiary
value may have been damaged," Lieutenant Nichols said. "What
could've been the proverbial nail in the coffin is now floating
around on TMZ.com instead. I don't think we can just download
that and bring it into court, but that's for the D.A. to decide."
The police said today that they had received calls from two
other suspects, Michael F. McClinton, 49, and Clarence J. Stewart
Jr., 54, both of Las Vegas, and hoped to bring them into custody
as early as tonight.
Hotel surveillance video and stills are being very useful
in the case, Lieutenant Nichols said. Mr. McClinton, Mr. Alexander
and Mr. Stewart all have been seen in video with Mr. Simpson
at the Palace Station on the night of the robbery, he said.
Police have cleared another man named earlier as a suspect,
Tom Scotto of New York City. Mr. Scotto was questioned and proved
to police he was elsewhere on Thursday night, Lieutenant Nichols
said. Two other men believed to have entered the hotel room
with Mr. Simpson have been tentatively identified, the officer
said.
Lieutenant Nichols said that Mr. Alexander was helpful in
the probe on Sunday when his attorney, Robert Rentzer of Los
Angeles, allowed him to be questioned on the condition that
nothing Mr. Alexander said could be used against him.
Lieutenant Nichols also cast doubt on Mr. Simpson's claim
that he rounded up a group of new acquaintances to go to the
room to retrieve the sports items. Rather, the officer said,
it appears Mr. Simpson had prior social relationships with all
of the men involved.
"This was not a grab-five-people-in-the-lobby-and-come-with-me
type of thing," Lieutenant Nichols said.
Mr. Simpson told The A.P. that he pretended to be interested
in buying the suit that he wore in court in 1995, when he was
acquitted of the murders of his former wife, Nicole Brown Simpson,
and her friend Ronald Goldman. The group left the room with
Mr. Simpson's Hall of Fame certificate and a photo of J. Edgar
Hoover, the former F.B.I. director, among other items, Mr. Simpson
said.
"Everybody knows this is stolen stuff," Mr. Simpson was quoted
as saying. "Not only wasn't there a break-in, but Riccio came
to the lobby and escorted us up to the room.
"In any event," Mr. Simpson was quoted as saying, "it's stolen
stuff that's mine. Nobody was roughed up."
Mr. Simpson was acquitted for the 1994 double murder, but
he was found liable for the deaths in a civil case in 1997 and
was ordered to pay the Goldman family $38 million and Ms. Simpson's
family $24 million. To date, he has paid about $10,000 of the
judgment, said a lawyer for the Goldman family, David J. Cook.
The Goldman family watched the case from afar with "cautious
optimism," said Mr. Goldman's father, Fred Goldman.
"He deserves whatever he gets," Mr. Goldman said. "It's only
satisfying that he's arrested. If he's convicted and sentenced
to jail, it'll be that much more satisfying. But when all is
said and done, he has still gotten away with murder and that's
where he should've been punished, that's where he should have
been found guilty and that's where he should've gotten the death
sentence."
The incident leading to the arrests came the night before
the release of "If I Did It," a book Mr. Simpson collaborated
on with a ghostwriter that he said was a fictional account of
how he might have committed the murders for which he was acquitted.
The book, originally to be published by HarperCollins last year
before an outcry prompted the company to cancel it, was repackaged
by the family of Mr. Goldman to make money to pay down the civil
judgment.
The Goldman family has been under criticism by members of
Ms. Simpson's family for publishing the gory account. Ms. Simpson's
sister, Denise Brown, appeared on Oprah Winfrey's talk show
on Thursday to denounce it, and Ms. Winfrey agreed that its
publication was distasteful.
Yet Mr. Goldman said the robbery arrest was another reason
why he wanted the book published.
"I hope people read it and I hope they see - I know they will
see - more of the same monster that they're seeing today in
that book," Mr. Goldman said.