LAS VEGAS — Four times, in a halting, broken voice, a humbled
O. J. Simpson said Friday, “I’m sorry.”
Yet for all his compunction about the September 2007 raid
and armed robbery at a casino hotel for which he was convicted
of 12 felonies, Mr. Simpson also continued to insist that he
did not think at the time that he had done anything illegal.
And so Judge Jackie Glass of Clark County District Court,
facing down the man acquitted in perhaps the most-watched murder
trial of the 20th century, scolded Mr. Simpson for his arrogance
and stupidity and sentenced him to a minimum of nine years in
state prison.
“The evidence was overwhelming,” Judge Glass said before pronouncing
sentence, first on one of Mr. Simpson’s five accomplices, Clarence
Stewart, 54, and then on Mr. Simpson himself.
Both men were convicted by the same jury of the same 12 charges,
including kidnapping and armed robbery, stemming from the incident
at the Palace Station Hotel-Casino. Mr. Simpson and five men,
at least two of whom carried guns, stole a trove of sports memorabilia
worth thousands of dollars from two collectibles dealers.
“It was a little-bitty room and a lot of you big guys in that
little-bitty room,” Judge Glass said. “That was ‘nobody leave
this room.’ That was actually a very violent event. Guns were
brought; one was displayed. The potential for harm to occur
in that room was tremendous.”
Mr. Simpson’s maximum sentence could be 33 years. Judge Glass
sentenced Mr. Stewart to a minimum of seven and a half years
and a maximum of 27 years. A Parole and Probation Division report
had recommended an 18-year minimum sentence for each man; prosecutors
said they had sought at least six years.
“It could’ve been a lot worse,” Mr. Simpson’s longtime lawyer,
Yale Galanter, said at a news conference. “It was one of those
days where you expect the worst, hope for the best and it turned
out better than we thought. Obviously he’s upset by the prospect
of facing nine years in prison, but I think he’s really relieved
he didn’t get a life sentence.”
Mr. Simpson, a Pro Football Hall of Famer, wore a blue prison
jumpsuit and shackles on his legs and wrists. Shortly before
he was sentenced, he rose and addressed the court for about
five minutes, his first comments in the courtroom throughout
the trial, and ones that Judge Glass said later that she had
not expected.
Mr. Simpson apologized repeatedly for the trouble he had caused
while restating his belief that the items he had sought in the
hotel room were rightfully his. They included trophies and family
photos that he said were stolen years ago from his Los Angeles
home and had ended up in the possession of the collectibles
dealers, Bruce L. Fromong and Alfred Beardsley.
“I didn’t want to hurt anybody,” Mr. Simpson insisted. “I
didn’t know I was doing anything wrong.”
In remarks leading up to the sentencing, Judge Glass repeatedly
insisted that neither she nor the jury had been influenced by
the 1995 trial in which a Los Angeles jury acquitted Mr. Simpson
in the murders of his former wife Nicole Brown Simpson, and
her friend Ronald L. Goldman.
“That doesn’t matter to me; I want that to be perfectly clear
to everyone,” she said, explaining that she gave Mr. Stewart
a shorter sentence because she felt he was less culpable.
A hearing to determine in which Nevada prison Mr. Simpson,
61, will serve his sentence will be held in coming weeks. Earlier
Friday, Judge Glass denied a defense motion that he be allowed
to remain free pending appeal.
The prosecutor, District Attorney David Roger, said he did
not think Mr. Simpson would be isolated from the rest of the
prison population, and Mr. Simpson’s lawyer Gabriel Grasso indicated
that he had not been separated from other inmates in the Clark
County Detention Center. He has been held there since he was
convicted on Oct. 3, exactly 13 years after his acquittal in
the killings of Ms. Simpson and Mr. Goldman. Mr. Simpson has
become popular among his fellow jail inmates, Mr. Grasso said,
because he buys candy for them with his own commissary money.
Neither Mr. Fromong nor Mr. Beardsley attended the sentencing.
Mr. Goldman’s father and sister did, though, and said they were
pleased by the outcome.
“There’s never closure; Ron is always gone,” the father, Fred
Goldman, said on the courthouse steps. “What we have is satisfaction
that this monster is where he belongs, behind bars.”
Four of Mr. Simpson’s accomplices pleaded guilty and testified
against him at the trial here, which played out like a very
low-key echo of his circuslike trial in Los Angeles in 1995.
Even the sentencing drew only a small cadre of publicity-seeking
figures, including, appropriately for Las Vegas, an Elvis Presley
impersonator.
While many legal experts said they did not think the case
would have gone to trial had it not centered on Mr. Simpson,
a noted Las Vegas criminal defense lawyer, Dayvid Figler, said
he was surprised and impressed that Judge Glass did not go harder
on him. “This sentence is not out of line with someone who would
be in a similar position as Simpson with those charges having
gone to trial,” said Mr. Figler, who also discussed the case
on truTV.
Lawyers for Mr. Simpson and Mr. Stewart said they would appeal
the convictions on several grounds. They argue that jury selection
was manipulated to produce a panel with no African-Americans
and that one juror claimed on a questionnaire not to have a
strong opinion about the 1995 trial but said in post-trial interviews
that Mr. Simpson should have been convicted 13 years ago.
“This isn’t the end for this legal team,” Mr. Galanter said.
“This is the beginning. There’s a long way to go. We’re not
going to leave any stone unturned.”
In a glittering career as a running back in the 1970s, Mr.
Simpson was one of the most famous football players of his generation.
But he became the prime suspect in the 1994 murder of Ms. Simpson,
who had divorced him two years earlier, and Mr. Goldman, outside
her home in the Brentwood section of Los Angeles.
The acquittal of Mr. Simpson, who has always vehemently maintained
his innocence in the killings, came at the end of a racially
charged trial.
Mr. Simpson was found liable for the deaths in a 1997 civil
suit and was ordered to pay damages to the victims’ families
totaling $33.5 million.
Little of the civil judgment has been collected, and the Goldman
family, which has vigorously pursued Mr. Simpson’s assets, is
expected to push for hearings to determine who owns the Simpson-related
items seized in the raid.