LAS VEGAS — This city, known for copies of the
Eiffel Tower, the Statue of Liberty and the canals of Venice,
now has another reproduction: the crime scene where the authorities
say O. J. Simpson took part in an armed robbery and kidnapping.
Prosecutors commissioned construction of a full-size model
of the 335-square-foot Palace Station Hotel-Casino room that
Mr. Simpson and five friends raided, departing with a trove
of keepsakes that Mr. Simpson said were rightfully his.
The replica, built of fiberboard in a basement conference
room at the Clark County Regional Justice Center complete with
a mock bed, two nightstands, armoire and desk, was rejected
as inadequate by Judge Jackie Glass. The judge took the jury
to the actual Palace Station room last Friday instead.
Some lawyers were surprised that District Attorney David Roger
would order such a thing constructed.
“This raises the fundamental question of how we’re going to
use prosecutorial resources and how we’re going to treat celebrity
defendants,” said Laurie Levenson, a former federal prosecutor.
Ms. Levenson said the only crime-scene reproductions she had
seen were in prison assault cases, because it is unsafe to walk
a jury into an actual jailhouse.
“For every dime spent on this case, that dime is not available
for another victim’s case,” she said.
Mr. Roger refuses to disclose the price of the fake room until
the trial is over. But John Crundwell, head of the lumber department
at a nearby Home Depot, estimated that it cost at least $2,000
in labor and building materials. Judge Glass had ruled that
she would not allow a visit to Palace Station because she feared
exposing the jury to a media circus, but she relented after
declaring that the model “doesn’t demonstrate the hotel room,”
said a court spokesman, Michael Sommermeyer. The visit was done
in secret early Friday, he said.
Mr. Sommermeyer said Mr. Roger wanted the jury to feel how
cramped the room was and to get a sense that all participants
“probably would have noticed things going on in the room.”
Jean Rosenbluth, a former federal prosecutor, said there were
other ways to give jurors the feel of a crime scene. “I probably
would have relied on the best photographs I could find,” said
Ms. Rosenbluth, who also noted that prosecutors often create
virtual tours using computer graphics. “There are all sorts
of cases where the jury doesn’t go to the scene of the crime.”
A Palace Station spokeswoman, Lori Nelson, said she was surprised
to hear of the reproduction. She said Room 1203 had been vacant
since the Simpson incident in September 2007 because her company
had not wanted to capitalize on its notoriety.
And what becomes of the fake room now?
“There’s no legal duty to retain it,” Ms. Levenson said. Noting
the irony that the case centers on what Mr. Simpson says are
stolen keepsakes, she wondered, “Hey, maybe it’ll be memorabilia
from the trial?”