LAS VEGAS: DOMINICK DUNNE wore his best shirt
the first day in the courtroom. He figured this was an O. J. Simpson
trial, and the last time he had gone to one a gantlet of paparazzi
had lined the courthouse entrance. He wanted to look spiffy.
It didn’t matter. There were almost no cameras.
“There is nobody here,” said Mr. Dunne, the chronicler of
celebrity crime, still disappointed on Friday as the first week
of testimony wrapped up.
Well, not nobody; Mr. Dunne, after all, is present. At 82
and battling bladder cancer, he traveled here against doctor’s
orders and his family’s wishes, to sit again in a courtroom,
where a different set of lawyers grill a different set of troubling
witnesses, but where the same defendant, Orenthal James Simpson,
awaits his fate.
Mr. Dunne says he wouldn’t think of missing it. Given his
declining health and his desire to write his memoirs, this may
be the last high-profile trial for Mr. Dunne, whose lengthy
first-person columns in Vanity Fair portray celebrity defendants
and his own personal celebrity. He has covered the courtroom
dramas of Claus von Bulow, William Kennedy Smith, Michael C.
Skakel and Phil Spector.
“An O. J. case is the perfect capper because he’s been such
a part of my life for 13 years,” said Mr. Dunne, whose virulent
criticism of Mr. Simpson, 61, in his writing and on Court TV,
caused defense lawyers to ask prospective jurors if they were
familiar with his work.
“I had a literary following before, but because of O. J. I
became a name and a public person, which I love,” Mr. Dunne
said. “I think it would be a fitting way to end.”
Mr. Dunne and the defendant are almost the only holdovers
here from the 1995 double-homicide trial at which Mr. Simpson
was acquitted. (The former prosecutor Marcia Clark, who failed
to convict Mr. Simpson on charges that he murdered his ex-wife
Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman requested
a press badge to report for “Entertainment Tonight,” but she
has not yet appeared.)
“There’s no excitement, no buzz outside,” Mr. Dunne said wistfully.
“It’s because there’s no body.”
Indeed, thi s trial is a vastly different business. Mr. Simpson
is charged with armed robbery and kidnapping stemming from a
confrontation in September 2007 in which he attempted to retrieve
sports memorabilia that he said had been taken from him.
The scene of the alleged crime was a $35-a-night hotel room
here. There is no bloody glove entered as evidence, only a series
of headache-inducing audio recordings by an ex-convict who set
up the confrontation and sold his tapes to a gossip Web site
before sharing them with the police.
Instead of two attractive young people stabbed in cold blood,
the victims are a pair of middle-aged men, collectibles dealers.
MR. DUNNE understands all that, now that he has sat through
five tedious days of testimony that included arcana about the
corruptibility of digital audio recordings. But to him it isn’t
just a mundane robbery case; it’s a mundane robbery case involving
one of the world’s most famous murder defendants.
“If O. J. was not at the center of this, there’s no way I
could even sit through this,” he said. “I just don’t care about
stolen footballs.”
Nor, it seems, do most Americans; they just want to find out
whether it ends any differently than the first trial, and whether,
if convicted on the most serious counts, Mr. Simpson will be
sentenced to the 15 years to life in prison he faces.
Mr. Simpson’s initial court appearances last year provoked
a minor frenzy, but his arrivals in recent days elicited little
reaction. A street outside the courthouse was shut down for
an expected deluge of reporters, but it has been largely empty.
The Las Vegas Sun is offering updates via the microblog site
Twitter, but as of Friday just 33 people had signed up.
The event is also playing out to a country preoccupied by
a crisis on Wall Street and the drama of a presidential race.
The quiet around the trial has made Mr. Dunne, a small, white-haired
figure with thick horn-rimmed glasses, one of the more intriguing
sidelights of the saga.
When a Simpson fan burst into the courtroom during a break
to get the defendant’s autograph, the sight of Mr. Dunne caused
her to let out a gasp. “It’s Dominick Dunne!” she exclaimed,
planting a kiss on him before bailiffs expelled her. There was
laughter, and Mr. Simpson quipped, “Hey, she’s after Dominick,
she’s not after me!”
Declining to work in a nearby press room where it is easier
to see and hear, Mr. Dunne prefers to soak up the atmosphere,
such as it is, in the back row of the Clark County courtroom.
He sits next to the door, the only person permitted by Judge
Jackie Glass to enter and exit while court is in session, a
concession to his health.
The notebooks in which h e scribbles have a sketch of his
own likeness on every page, pads made for him for his occasional
TruTV series, “Dominick Dunne’s Power, Privilege and Justice.”
Even Mr. Simpson, whose guilt in the double murder Mr. Dunne
has vehemently argued, is deferential. Mr. Dunne said he was
nervous when Mr. Simpson, a former professional football player,
approached him on the trial’s first day, but the defendant just
smiled and complimented him on his TV show.
Could Mr. Dunne and his arch-nemesis be enjoying a détente?
“I suppose I have felt a bit of empathy, but he killed two
people,” Mr. Dunne said. “I don’t give a damn about the armed
robbery. The other was a criminal act of the worst kind. I have
seen the severed head of Nicole and what your throat looks like
after it’s been cut open.”
But there’s “a loneliness, a sadness about O. J. that I never
saw before,” he said. “I think he understands how wrecked his
life is.”
The columnist plans to stay through the end of the second
week of what is expected to be a five-week trial because he
must return to New York for a medical procedure related to his
cancer. He will return to Las Vegas, he says, for the conclusion.
He also suspects — and hopes — that the case could get good
by then.20Mr. Simpson’s lawyers began laying the groundwork
on Thursday for a defense that will resonate with anyone familiar
with the 1995 case: He is being persecuted by police officers
willing to manipulate evidence.
“I listened to two guys in the bathroom today, two white guys
who had nothing to do with this case, and they totally believe
he was set up,” Mr. Dunne said. “I don’t know if he was, but
it would sure help the trial.”