GOODSPRINGS, Nev. — It was 7-year-old Briana Lloyd’s
turn to ring the bell signaling the start of the day at Goodsprings
Elementary School. Clearly excited, she tugged the cord and the
peals echoed through this town in the barren desert hills 35 miles
southwest of Las Vegas.
Then Briana and her classmates lined up around the flagpole
to recite the Pledge of Allegiance. It did not take long for
the student body to assemble.
Ninety-six-year-old Goodsprings Elementary is a three-room
schoolhouse with just six students: a fifth-grader, four fourth-graders
and Briana, who is in first grade. If no one else moves to town,
she will be the only student left at the start of the 2010-11
school year.
The board of the Clark County School District was poised to
close Goodsprings Elementary in May, but protests from parents
and residents persuaded the board to delay the decision a year.
The T-shaped, 1,800-square-foot, sand-colored building costs
$220,450 annually in salaries and utilities, or approximately
$36,742 per pupil, according to district data. That is more
than five times as much as the $7,000 per-pupil average for
the district, which serves about 300,000 students in mostly
overcrowded urban schools where classes of over 30 children
are common.
“I can understand the community pride, but when you get down
to the harsh realities, it is very expensive per pupil here,”
said the Goodsprings principal, Mark Jones, who also oversees
Sandy Valley Elementary, Middle and High Schools, about 12 miles
away.
“When you get into survival mode, when you get into severe
budget cuts,” Mr. Jones said, “sentimentality, while it’s understandable,
shouldn’t be the deciding factor.”
The sentimentality in Goodsprings, though, is formidable.
Perhaps because it is so close to Las Vegas, where old structures
are famously imploded and replaced rather than preserved, the
county’s oldest operating school represents an unusually durable
tie to regional history.
The town itself, an 1829 stop along the original Old Spanish
Trail, boomed in the early 20th century as miners extracted
zinc and lead from the hills. When the school was built in 1913,
the population of Goodsprings was about 800. (Fewer than 2,000
people lived in Las Vegas.)
A post-World War II mining bust led many residents to leave;
today the town has only 200 people and two businesses — a saloon
and a general store — so most residents work in Las Vegas.
But the school, put on the National Register of Historic Places
in 1997, remains central to local life. Gone are its potbellied
stove, water pump and wooden outhouses, and a 1996 renovation
brought computers and new flooring, but the bell Briana rang
is the original and students still perform a Christmas pageant
every year.
Julie Newberry, who taught at the school from 1982 until she
retired in 1999 and who has become a de facto school historian,
said the nine decades of old report cards and class lists she
has collected could double as genealogy charts for the town.
Briana’s father and grandmother are graduates, as will be her
brother Eddie Lloyd, a fourth grader.
“The students develop a real sense of pride in the school,
a real sense of family because, in many cases, they are family,”
Mrs. Newberry said.
Should the district close the school, several residents said,
it will represent a devastating blow to the town’s viability.
The county already closed a full-time post office and eliminated
the voting precinct, requiring residents to vote by mail.
“But the biggest loss would be the school,” said Elizabeth
Warren, a founder of the Goodsprings Historical Society, “because
the school has always been here.”
Ms. Warren, whose children attended Goodsprings Elementary,
said she doubted the accuracy of the district’s per-pupil calculations.
“Other people who don’t live here, who aren’t a part of this
community, are dismantling this community,” she said. “It will
be reduced to being a subdivision. They take away the heart
and soul of the community if you take away the school.”
A school board trustee, Carolyn Edwards, who represents the
region, led the effort to delay the vote on the closing to give
residents a chance to make a case for saving the school. Still,
she said, “when you get down to one or two students, you can
tell it’s ridiculous. I don’t think you keep a school open solely
because it’s an historic building.”
Dana Rhoades, whose daughter Megan is a fifth grader, insisted
that she was fighting to preserve not just a school building
but the individual attention it affords the students. Rather
than close Goodsprings Elementary and force Briana and perhaps
other students to attend larger classes in Sandy Valley, Mrs.
Rhoades said, the district should send Sandy Valley Elementary
students needing more attention to Goodsprings.
Such an arrangement, Mr. Jones argued, is not cost-effective.
He said high test scores at Sandy Valley show that students
there receive an education comparable to that in Goodsprings.
Classes average 15 students, still well below the districtwide
average, he said, and keeping Goodsprings open also comes at
a price to students in larger urban schools.
“The people who would like to keep this open, I would like
to have them go and talk to the other parents and say, ‘By the
way, we’re going to be able to keep our one-teacher schoolhouse
open, but maybe you’re not going to have a band program or freshman
sports or a debate team or a drama club or whatever,’ ” Mr.
Jones said.
Mr. Jones and other school and county officials said they
were unsure what would become of the building if the school
were to close. The town has no taxing authority to raise the
money needed to maintain it, and the library district and the
county have declined offers to use it. Ms. Edwards said she
hoped to come up with some way to preserve it.
Briana is unconcerned at the prospect of being Goodsprings
Elementary’s only student starting in September 2010.
“I don’t mind that,” she said, “but about closing the school,
I don’t like it because the school’s been open a real long time,
and it needs to stay open.”